Update:
I wrote this comment and posted it, before reading youssef's comment on PTT Debate on Viva Palestinia, his comment at PTT, posted below, explained his subtitle, Galloway is no Salah Eddin,
Yousef met many thieves,
So why someone like Galloway is beyond this ? Thus asked Yousef
However, he was more careful that his colleague.
************
I wrote this comment and posted it, before reading youssef's comment on PTT Debate on Viva Palestinia, his comment at PTT, posted below, explained his subtitle, Galloway is no Salah Eddin,
Yousef met many thieves,
So why someone like Galloway is beyond this ? Thus asked Yousef
However, he was more careful that his colleague.
************
Dear Yousef.
Many Arabs believe Nasralla is Salah Eddin, I never heard Galloway or anybody claiming that Galloway is Salah Eddin. Reading in between your lines,
"If the true supporter of the struggle understands this, then our struggle will become that much easier." and your title: Mubarak is no Abdul Nasser and Galloway is no Salah Eddin. I may conclude the you don't consider Galloway a true supporter, in other words he have an Irani Agenda as somebody claimed or at least, ort at the best he don't understand the basics of our Struggle with the Zionist entity.
As for Mubarak, he is a Zionist Puppet, and I wonder how you dare to compare?I wonder how dare to speak on behalf everyone:
"It’s hard to understand why anyone would want to send medical supplies in a break the siege effort through Egypt, and not cut through the borders from Lebanon or Jordan, (which is closer),
I wonder why you are so sure that cutting through the borders from Lebanon or Jordan "will guarantee the collapse of the siege and the collapse of the state that is imposing it."
The heart disease can't "be treated by putting a band aid on it." nor can be treated with pain killers, I mean international solidarity movement. The only treatment is resistance, its the Palestinian Blood who gave momentum to international solidarity movement. And its Jordon, Egypt and PA who are Protecting The Zionist Entity.
Finally Comrade Yousef
Mallouh is Neither Habash, nor Abu Ali Mustafa, Nor Saadat, who he should remain behind bars, and off course Khaida Jarrar is not Layla Khalid.
In his Last Years Retired Habash said: We failed Let Hamas (Not Abbas) TRY.
The zionist rough state of "Israel" is the problem By Yousef Abudayyeh
Mubarak is no Abdul Nasser and Galloway is no Salah Eddin
It’s a fact that most of the Arab people everywhere believe that their Arab rulers are corrupt to the core and that for them to stay in power they need to be in bed with the US, which always works against the Arab people’s aspiration for freedom and democracy. The misery and oppression that most of Arab people live under is a direct result of this unholy relationship and alliance.
It’s also a fact that the Zionist state that was implanted into the Arab World body more than 62 years ago, is fully supported by the US, the EU and many in the so-called World Community, even though this rogue body is illegal and does not abide by any of the international laws and resolutions. [You fotgot the mention the Arabs protecting the Zionist entity borders]
I know of no Arab person, and certainly, no Arab Palestinian, who is not grateful for the support our people and struggle for liberation and freedom get from Internationals, be it vocal or material .The fact is, many Internationals were killed, wounded or jailed by the Zionist rogue state, simply because they were standing in defense of a defenseless people. These people will always be etched in our memory and history and one day soon, when Palestine is liberated from the River to the Sea, will be honored as true freedom fighters. All through our struggle, many from pretty much everywhere on this globe joined – with no preset conditions – our march for freedom and they gave it their all.
What these freedom fighters had, which many in the current supporters of Palestine lack, is the true understanding of our struggle, which is really very simple to understand: Our homeland is colonized by a foreign force, and our people due to this colonization were forced to flee their homes and homeland, and have been scattered all over the map for more than 6 decades, but for not one moment did they gave up their dream of going back to Palestine. For not one moment did they believe that they will never liberate Palestine, even though, they can understand the huge odds against them. If the true supporter of the struggle understands this, then our struggle will become that much easier.
Without understanding that ‘Israel’ is the core problem in the Arab World, and trying to fashion methods to cripple this colonizing body, all will fail. It’s crucial for all the Internationals who are working in support of Palestine to work against the Zionist colonizers of Palestine. This work should start by forcing their respective governments to stop any kind of support of ‘Israel’, and should continue by facing the Zionists. Doing it face to face in defense of the defenseless Palestinians, like many did and are still doing on the ground in colonized Palestine.
That’s why it’s hard to understand why anyone would want to send medical supplies in a break the siege effort through Egypt, and not cut through the borders from Lebanon or Jordan, (which is closer), and be in direct contact with the rogue state that is imposing the siege on the Palestinian people in the first place. Egypt and Jordan and Saudi Arabia, etc., are implicated in much more than enforcing the siege, but the address for imposing that siege and committing war crimes is ‘Israel’. Why the Internationals are not doing this is beyond anyone’s understanding. It’s the only method that will guarantee the collapse of the siege and the collapse of the state that is imposing it.
So unless these Internationals believe that they can export revolution into Egypt, so the traitor Mubarak Regime can collapse and the border between Gaza and Egypt then can be cracked open, I for one can not see the reason for not tackling the core problem, i.e., ‘Israel’ head on, unless they believe that a heart disease can be treated by putting a band aid on it.
I guess, but not sure, you are Pro-FPLP uprooted Palestinian, and if So, You should know the implication of putting the international Solidarity movement at odds with Lebanon, and our Major supporter Hezbollah.
Finally Comrade YousefAs an Uprooted Palestinian, deported on 1955 from Bint Jbeal to Ein Elhelwe refugee camp, as a student of the old guards of Arab Nationalist Movement, I would end my comment saying:
Mallouh is Neither Habash, nor Abu Ali Mustafa, Nor Saadat, who he should remain behind bars, and off course Khaida Jarrar is not Layla Khalid.
In his Last Years Retired Habash said: We failed Let Hamas (Not Abbas) TRY.
The zionist rough state of "Israel" is the problem By Yousef Abudayyeh
Mubarak is no Abdul Nasser and Galloway is no Salah Eddin
Via We Shall Return
The Queen of Free Minds changed the Title to read:
Mubarak is no Abdul Nasser and Galloway is no Salah Eddin, but ‘Israel’ is the problem.
The Queen of Free Minds changed the Title to read:
Mubarak is no Abdul Nasser and Galloway is no Salah Eddin, but ‘Israel’ is the problem.
It’s a fact that most of the Arab people everywhere believe that their Arab rulers are corrupt to the core and that for them to stay in power they need to be in bed with the US, which always works against the Arab people’s aspiration for freedom and democracy. The misery and oppression that most of Arab people live under is a direct result of this unholy relationship and alliance.
It’s also a fact that the Zionist state that was implanted into the Arab World body more than 62 years ago, is fully supported by the US, the EU and many in the so-called World Community, even though this rogue body is illegal and does not abide by any of the international laws and resolutions. [You fotgot the mention the Arabs protecting the Zionist entity borders]
I know of no Arab person, and certainly, no Arab Palestinian, who is not grateful for the support our people and struggle for liberation and freedom get from Internationals, be it vocal or material .The fact is, many Internationals were killed, wounded or jailed by the Zionist rogue state, simply because they were standing in defense of a defenseless people. These people will always be etched in our memory and history and one day soon, when Palestine is liberated from the River to the Sea, will be honored as true freedom fighters. All through our struggle, many from pretty much everywhere on this globe joined – with no preset conditions – our march for freedom and they gave it their all.
What these freedom fighters had, which many in the current supporters of Palestine lack, is the true understanding of our struggle, which is really very simple to understand: Our homeland is colonized by a foreign force, and our people due to this colonization were forced to flee their homes and homeland, and have been scattered all over the map for more than 6 decades, but for not one moment did they gave up their dream of going back to Palestine. For not one moment did they believe that they will never liberate Palestine, even though, they can understand the huge odds against them. If the true supporter of the struggle understands this, then our struggle will become that much easier.
Without understanding that ‘Israel’ is the core problem in the Arab World, and trying to fashion methods to cripple this colonizing body, all will fail. It’s crucial for all the Internationals who are working in support of Palestine to work against the Zionist colonizers of Palestine. This work should start by forcing their respective governments to stop any kind of support of ‘Israel’, and should continue by facing the Zionists. Doing it face to face in defense of the defenseless Palestinians, like many did and are still doing on the ground in colonized Palestine.
That’s why it’s hard to understand why anyone would want to send medical supplies in a break the siege effort through Egypt, and not cut through the borders from Lebanon or Jordan, (which is closer), and be in direct contact with the rogue state that is imposing the siege on the Palestinian people in the first place. Egypt and Jordan and Saudi Arabia, etc., are implicated in much more than enforcing the siege, but the address for imposing that siege and committing war crimes is ‘Israel’. Why the Internationals are not doing this is beyond anyone’s understanding. It’s the only method that will guarantee the collapse of the siege and the collapse of the state that is imposing it.
So unless these Internationals believe that they can export revolution into Egypt, so the traitor Mubarak Regime can collapse and the border between Gaza and Egypt then can be cracked open, I for one can not see the reason for not tackling the core problem, i.e., ‘Israel’ head on, unless they believe that a heart disease can be treated by putting a band aid on it.
Posted by Yousef Abudayyeh at 1:47 PM
Yousef Abudayyeh on December 31st, 2009 at 1:47:
who is defending Egypt? I have read the exchange and have not found that Haitham is defending Egypt or the PA . Actually he called them the corrupt PA . So what is this all about ?
And why are people surprised that someone like Galloway is in this for a reason other than breaking the siege ?
His actions in the three Viva Palestina efforts all proves that he did make at least one deal with the Egyptians in every effort in complete disregard to the letter and spirit of the mission .
People, and I can name many Palestinian national leaders benefited from the suffering of our people many times and many are still are. So why someone like Galloway is beyond this ?
Why are you afraid of facing the loud and clear facts that is coming from people who dealt with these types first hand ?
I believe that knowing the facts will help our people and their true supporters weed out the bad apples. Anyone who attacks Dr. Mona El Farra in front of the Viva Palestina US participants and brought her to tears because she suggested that some of the money be used to buy an essential medical equipment for the Shiffa Hospital instead of buying brand new Toyota sedans totaling $500,000.00 does not respect our struggle, our people under siege and their suffering and does not have the best interest for us .Why people are surprised is beyond me.
River to Sea
Uprooted Palestinian
Yousef Abudayyeh on December 31st, 2009 at 1:47:
who is defending Egypt? I have read the exchange and have not found that Haitham is defending Egypt or the PA . Actually he called them the corrupt PA . So what is this all about ?
And why are people surprised that someone like Galloway is in this for a reason other than breaking the siege ?
His actions in the three Viva Palestina efforts all proves that he did make at least one deal with the Egyptians in every effort in complete disregard to the letter and spirit of the mission .
People, and I can name many Palestinian national leaders benefited from the suffering of our people many times and many are still are. So why someone like Galloway is beyond this ?
Why are you afraid of facing the loud and clear facts that is coming from people who dealt with these types first hand ?
I believe that knowing the facts will help our people and their true supporters weed out the bad apples. Anyone who attacks Dr. Mona El Farra in front of the Viva Palestina US participants and brought her to tears because she suggested that some of the money be used to buy an essential medical equipment for the Shiffa Hospital instead of buying brand new Toyota sedans totaling $500,000.00 does not respect our struggle, our people under siege and their suffering and does not have the best interest for us .Why people are surprised is beyond me.
River to Sea
Uprooted Palestinian
Where is my shoes??
ReplyDeleteLet's assume that the Egyptian government was replaced with new democratically elected one, what do you think would happen?
ReplyDeleteBelieve me, it is very simple.The tag Is ready: Eygpt for is a terrorist state. Full Stop!
Who can guarantee that the newly elected government and its president will not be the same as the previous regime?
Israel will rush to occupy Gazan borders again (let's say they will intensify their occupation and bring back their soldiers to Gaza/Egypt borders).
The Zionists will find it the moment of history when they can establish their dream of Greater Israel. They might not only occupy Sinai, but invade Egypt across the Red Sea until Israel reaches the Nile. What may happen next is another story.
If the existing regime in Egypt or a newly elected one opens the borders with Gaza in the present conditions of Palestine, without any international guarantees that Palestine is going to be autonomous in controlling its own borders for the good of the people in Palestine and not to serve factions whose agendas are not acceptable to any patriot.
LONG LIVE MUBARAK AND THE IRON WALL
Check It here
It is certainly interesting for me to read that blog. Thanks for it. I like such themes and everything that is connected to them. I definitely want to read more soon.
ReplyDeleteBella Benedict