Alan Hart said: "Israel has no right to exist unless it was recognized and legitimized by those who were dispossessed of their land and their rights during the creation of the Zionist state."
Here, I fully agree with Mr. Hart, and would add Palestinians "dispossessed of their land and their rights during the creation of the Zionist state." will never recognize IsraelALAN HART also said: Zionism’s Colonial Enterprise Is Doomed, but…
My Problem with Alan Hart is his "But".
He claimed that the Palestine file was closed with the Israeli 1948 Victory, that Arafat re-opened the file.
No Sir, the Palestine file was not closed in 1948, nor was re-opened by your Friend "Father Palestine"
Your other Friend Golda (Mother Israel), though she denied the existence of my people, she knew that Israel her daughter is doomed and "has no right to exist unless it was by those who were dispossessed of their land and their rights during the creation of the Zionist state".
"Father Palestine" used resistance to undermine the Arab nationalist's movement, and when done, He move to undermine the Resistance and the first Intifada on his long way to close the Palestine File. He failed and was killed for his failure. I am not going to repeat what I wrote commenting on your Article: Annual Nakba Commemoration Dinner Speech.
I posted your speech at my blog, and placed a link to it at your site. The Link never appeared because you want us to believe that your Friend "Father Palestine" reopened the Palestine File, closed in 1948 war as you claimed.
Here as Nahida rightfully said you're putting us between two options, Sampson's option or the so called "two-state solution".
Thirty years ago, Mother Israel frightened you at a point and you interrupted her to say: “Prime Minister, I want to be sure I understand what you’re saying… You are saying that if ever Israel was in danger of being defeated on the battlefield, it would be prepared to take the region and even the whole world down with it?”
"Without the shortest of pauses for reflection, and in the gravel voice that could charm or intimidate American Presidents according to need, Golda replied, “Yes, that’s exactly what I am saying.” "
Yes Sir, "Zionism’s colonial enterprise was doomed by its failure to keep the Palestine file closed."
The two greatest opposites Mother Israel and "Father Palestine" failed to close the file, and it will only be closed by Uprooted Palestinians, Resistance, armed and popular, the International freedom movement and proud self- hating Jews like Gilad Atzmon, who come from them, and he know how they think.
Alan Hart: Israel has no right to exist